John D. Yordy (Interim President), 2004-06
Shirley H. Showalter, 1997-2004
Henry D. Weaver, (Interim President), 1996
Victor S. Stoltzfus, 1984-96
J. Lawrence Burkholder, 1971-84
Paul E. Mininger, 1954-70
Carl Kreider (Acting President), 1950-51, 1970-71
Ernest E. Miller, 1940-54
Sanford C. Yoder, 1923-40
Daniel Kauffman, 1922-23
Irvin R. Detweiler (Acting President), 1920-22
Henry Frank Reist, 1919-20
George J. Lapp, 1918-19
John E. Hartzler, 1913-18
Noah E. Byers, 1901-13

Noah E. Byers, 1898-1903
Willis E. Tower, 1895-98
Rev. F.A. Hosmer, 1894-95