The West Goodrich Prairie was established on 11 acres of active and abandoned cropland. About four acres of the site was cropland abandoned in 1992 as a result of its discovery that it was within the existing Merry Lea State Nature Preserve boundaries. Over the ensuing ten years exotic autumn olive shrubs invaded this abandoned area. In December 2010 the autumn olive, and all other woody vegetation, was removed by mechanical means. During the 2011 growing season, the sod on this area was broadcast treated twice with herbicide. Follow-up herbicide treatment was done on any residual stump sprouts. In April 2012 the entire eleven-acre site was divided into three management units and no-till planted with a mesic native seed mix. In August 2012, 33 ft. wide cool season vegetation firebreaks were planted between the three units. A 16 ft. wide perimeter firebreak was also planted around the entire site. The same early establishment techniques were used as with the Luckey Prairie.
As of 2016, this site is being used by Goshen College Biological Sciences faculty member Dr. Ryan Sensenig and his students to study the potential for sustainably grazing domestic livestock on native prairie plant species (link to project on BSD website?). An additional acre of adjoining land was planted with species used in the firebreaks in order to provide a relief forage area (along with the wider firebreaks) for the livestock.